#BookReview – The Threats of Sky and Sea Trilogy by Jennifer Ellision #fantasy #YAfantasy

One week on and I’m still not up to doing anything creative myself yet, so today I’m sharing my review of a box set – you can see my review of Book 1 here, and you can clearly see I enjoyed it enough to go on and buy the set!

Elementals: The Threats of Sky and Sea Trilogy (Elementals: The Threats of Sky and Sea series)Elementals: The Threats of Sky and Sea Trilogy by Jennifer Ellision
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I began this journey hesitantly, not being a fan of books in present tense, but found after a little perseverance that the story and characters in book 1 dragged me in so deep I almost forgot my prejudice. The world building, and the breathless twists and turns, particularly the big reveal at the end, had me gripped, and I went on immediately to buy the box set of all three.
I found it intriguing also, that although my preference is for simple, invisible prose, where this author never uses a simple word where a more complex one fits the bill, I rather enjoyed the style. Kudos to the author for achieving this.
Book 2 was pretty standard construction for the middle section of a trilogy – a journey with many trials and losses, plus some discoveries and compromises bringing our heroes by the end to the place they need to be to launch the finale.
Book 3. Now, this was enjoyable and exciting as a wrap up, although for me, a couple of issues arose that I found a touch hard to swallow. (Spoilers ahead) Bree has been unmasked as the real queen by birth of the island kingdom of Nereid, and yet, having only just begun to settle into her role, no one questions her waltzing off again, to face a powerful mad king on his home turf. I really felt someone might at least have tried to stop her, for her own safety if nothing else. And during her confrontation with an earth shaker, her powers somehow seemed to be markedly less than they had been before, which seemed to me to be a plot device to get certain characters captured and placed in mortal danger. Perhaps I missed something here, but that’s how it read to me.
So, with those bits in book 3 just taking the edge off for me, this box set makes a 4-star read. I’d still recommend it to fantasy lovers looking for unique world building and strong characters, provided you are happy with reading in the present tense.

View all my reviews

Find the box set on Amazon.com here

Advertisements

7 comments

  1. Take care of yourself, Deborah. And–the book sounds good! Elementals–pretty exciting.

    1. Thanks Jacqui, and the Elemental angle was what attracted me to the series in the first place. I love to see what other authors do with it, and I enjoyed this game on the subject.

  2. Nothing like getting lost in a good book Deb. Wonderful reviews and I’ll check out the set too. We all need a creative break. Just take it in. ❤

    1. Cheers ❤️

  3. Interesting review, Deborah. The series sounds good despite the drawbacks. I too notice when a book’s “reality” bends to accommodate a plot. I’m glad to know that overall it was a fun read. 😀

    1. It’s one of the things my writer’s group is very hot at identifying – we never let each other get away with it!

      1. I was going to say it’s one reason why a good beta reader is like gold. But a writer’s group is even better!

Leave a Reply to Deborah Jay Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: